CHARLOTTE — When you're 1-5, on your second head coach of the season, and don't have what you'd call any stability at quarterback, you're kind of an easy mark for criticism. But as the Panthers front office looks into the future, they see the makings of what they consider a stable plan and the kind of flexibility they want to add to it next year and beyond.
While they've taken some flak since letting coach Matt Rhule go for having no clear blueprint for 2023 at coach and quarterback — and those are two really big factors — there are also many of the other pieces in place once they fill in those two blanks next offseason.
While sometimes described as "a mess" on Twitter for the lack of cap space in 2023 — and 280 characters allows little in the way of context — they also have fewer needs [beyond quarterback] than some other teams, and enough starters under contract through next year or beyond to make it a shorter shopping list anyway. And without any kind of broader view, the information that's out there often paints a misleading picture of what's going on at the moment.
"There actually is a plan in place," Panthers vice president of football administration Samir Suleiman said, the understatement evident. "Cap space is always a fluid thing, but we've got a multi-year plan in place that accounts for a lot of scenarios. And a lot of the things you'd want to spend it on is already in place here."
And what's on hand includes the big-ticket items, the kinds of things that are expensive to obtain if you don't have them.
Of their current 22 starters on offense and defense, 20 are under contract for next year [everything but the quarterback and defensive tackle Matt Ioannidis].
That includes a pass-rusher [Brian Burns], a left tackle [Ikem Ekwonu], a top cornerback [Jaycee Horn ], and a top-shelf wide receiver [DJ Moore, who was signed to his deal at a time when receiver contracts were exploding league-wide], all home-grown players who were chosen in the first round. Reasonable minds can differ on the order you'd put them in, but if you ranked positions in order of importance and expense, that represents four of the top five. Throw in defensive tackle Derrick Brown [playing his best football now and under contractual control through at least 2024] and a playmaking safety in Jeremy Chinn, and it's a solid young group of players — but most importantly, most of the premium positions are boxes checked off.
"The point is, having those core guys already here is something we've planned for," Suleiman said.
So while they might not have the kind of cap room next offseason to make major purchases [like last offseason when they signed eight starters before or during the free agency period [Ioannidis, Xavier Woods, Damien Wilson, Austin Corbett, and returning starters Moore, Donte Jackson, Frankie Luvu, and Ian Thomas], they also don't have as many holes to fill. Of that group, only Ioannidis was signed to a one-year deal.
The entire offensive line, as it stands now, is under contract for next year, as is the entire secondary. Those two position groups have been strengths so far this year, things you want to build on.
There are also easy buttons to push to create cap space through cuts, trades, or restructures.
For instance, Burns is on the books now for $16 million in 2023 for his fifth-year option. An extension for a player they want to extend would bring his cap number down, immediately adding more room. They created $12 million worth of 2023 cap room by trading Robbie Anderson Monday. There are also $85 million in non-guaranteed deals on the books in 2023, meaning there's flexibility to create space in chunks with releases or restructures if they need to, but they aren't in a spot other teams have been in, which require major purges to get into compliance with the cap.
And even if they added a high-drafted quarterback to the mix, his first-year cap number would be around $7 million next year [a fraction of what they have tied up in Baker Mayfield and Sam Darnold this season].
That quarterback could walk into a ready-made offensive line with Moore on the outside, and that's not the worst place to be. As general manager Scott Fitterer witnessed in Seattle, having pieces in place before the quarterback gets there creates an environment for a rookie quarterback to succeed.
It's also worth noting that cap numbers can be worked with, and there are few teams who fiddle with numbers to stay in compliance annually; the Panthers aren't in that spot next year. They've worked through years with more dead money on the books [which is the kind of thing that happens during regime changes, especially during the COVID years], and aren't in that spot now, even figuring in a hit for the Anderson deal.
They also have built in future ability to do things by planning ahead. Beyond the guys on their rookie deals, they're getting solid value out of players on multi-years like Woods, Corbett, and Luvu, along with punter Johnny Hekker, an All-Decade player on a three-year contract.
And looking ahead, they're projected to have more than $80 million in cap space in 2024 and more than $145 million in 2025 [and those are conservative projections, which don't include the possibility of the cap rising with new television deals].
There are significant expenditures that will cut into those sums, of course, as players such as Burns and Brown [and Horn if he continues on his current trajectory] won't be cheap. And unless a drafted quarterback provides value on the field, a low cap number won't be that much of an advantage.
Again, the Panthers are 1-5 and have no idea who their coach or quarterback will be next year. That's not nothing. But they also have enough things in place that cap space or a plan for the future aren't nearly the factors some people think they are.
1 / 108
DT - 99 - Matt Ioannidis
2 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers
4 / 108
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
5 / 108
WR - Shi Smith
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
6 / 108
RB - Chuba Hubbard
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
7 / 108
WR - Terrace Marshall Jr.
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
8 / 108
S - Xavier Woods
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
9 / 108
TE - Ian Thomas
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
10 / 108
LB - Brandon Smith
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
11 / 108
CB - Donte Jackson
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
12 / 108
DE - Brian Burns
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
13 / 108
WR - Rashard Higgins
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
14 / 108
RB - Chuba Hubbard
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
15 / 108
TE - Ian Thomas
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
16 / 108
WR - Shi Smith
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
17 / 108
WR - Laviska Shenault Jr.
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
18 / 108
DT - Phil Hoskins
19 / 108
DT - 95 - Derrick Brown
20 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
21 / 108
CB - 28 - Keith Taylor Jr.
22 / 108
T - 72 - Taylor Moton
23 / 108
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
24 / 108
WR - 2 - DJ Moore
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
25 / 108
CB - 32 - Tae Hayes
26 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
27 / 108
CB - 26 - Donte Jackson
28 / 108
CB - 32 - Tae Hayes
29 / 108
P - 10 - Johnny Hekker
30 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
31 / 108
DT - 99 - Matt Ioannidis
32 / 108
LB - 55 - Cory Littleton
33 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
35 / 108
DE - 53 - Brian Burns
36 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
37 / 108
RB - 20 - Raheem Blackshear
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
38 / 108
TE - 84 - Stephen Sullivan
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
39 / 108
TE - 84 - Stephen Sullivan
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
40 / 108
CB - 24 - CJ Henderson
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
41 / 108
WR - 12 - Shi Smith
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
42 / 108
DT - 71 - Phil Hoskins
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
43 / 108
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
44 / 108
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
45 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
46 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
47 / 108
S - 42 - Sam Franklin Jr.
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
48 / 108
LB - 7 - Shaq Thompson
Steve Wilks
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
49 / 108
P - 10 - Johnny Hekker
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
50 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
51 / 108
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
52 / 108
LB - 55 - Cory Littleton
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
53 / 108
WR - 88 - Terrace Marshall Jr.
Chanelle Smith-Walker/Carolina Panthers
54 / 108
S - 25 - Xavier Woods
Carolina Panthers
55 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers
56 / 108
Carolina Panthers
57 / 108
Carolina Panthers
58 / 108
Carolina Panthers
59 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers
60 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers
61 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
Carolina Panthers
62 / 108
RB - 30 - Chuba Hubbard
Carolina Panthers
66 / 108
S - 31 - Juston Burris
67 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
68 / 108
Carolina Panthers
69 / 108
Carolina Panthers
72 / 108
CB - 26 - Donte Jackson
73 / 108
Carolina Panthers
75 / 108
DE - 53 - Brian Burns
Carolina Panthers
76 / 108
RB - 22 - Christian McCaffrey
Carolina Panthers
77 / 108
Carolina Panthers
79 / 108
S - 42 - Sam Franklin Jr.
Carolina Panthers
80 / 108
Carolina Panthers
81 / 108
Carolina Panthers
82 / 108
Carolina Panthers
83 / 108
Carolina Panthers
84 / 108
Carolina Panthers
85 / 108
S - 25 - Xavier Woods
Carolina Panthers
86 / 108
DE - 53 - Brian Burns
Carolina Panthers
87 / 108
Carolina Panthers
88 / 108
Carolina Panthers
89 / 108
Carolina Panthers
90 / 108
Carolina Panthers
91 / 108
Carolina Panthers
92 / 108
DT - 95 - Derrick Brown
93 / 108
P - 10 - Johnny Hekker
Carolina Panthers
94 / 108
Carolina Panthers
95 / 108
Carolina Panthers
96 / 108
Carolina Panthers
97 / 108
LB - 7 - Shaq Thompson
Carolina Panthers
98 / 108
Carolina Panthers
99 / 108
Carolina Panthers
100 / 108
Carolina Panthers
101 / 108
Carolina Panthers
102 / 108
Carolina Panthers
103 / 108
Carolina Panthers
104 / 108
QB - 11 - P.J. Walker
Carolina Panthers
105 / 108
Carolina Panthers
106 / 108
QB - 16 - Jacob Eason
Carolina Panthers
107 / 108
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
108 / 108
DE - 53 - Brian Burns
Kenny Richmond/Carolina Panthers
What will the NFL salary cap be in 2025?
NFL and NFLPA Look Forward to the Future Salary Cap.
What will the NFL salary cap be in 2026?
If the models projecting future years of the NFL salary cap are accurate, it could approach $230 million in 2023. Realistically, a $300 million NFL salary cap is possible by the 2026 season if the current trends continue.
Who will have the most cap space in 2023 NFL?
The Chicago Bears are No. 1 with an astounding $110.8 million of projected room under the cap.
Who will have the most cap space next year NFL?
NFL Team Salary Cap Tracker.