Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?

Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?

When presenting some event or activity dependent on a response makes that response more likely in the future, we say that reinforcement of the response has occurred. This sometimes is described as the strengthening effect of a reinforcer. It is by far the most well- known reinforcer effect. There are, however, at least two other effects of reinforcers on responding that are less talked about, but important nonetheless.

Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?
A positive discriminative stimulus, or “ess-dee” (for S-D) as it sometimes is called, is one in the presence of which a response is reinforced. A negative discriminative stimulus, or “ess delta” is one in the presence of which the response is not reinforced. Because the reinforcer always occurs after a response, the reinforcer can come to serve as a stimulus. As a stimulus, it can signal whether the next response is likely to be reinforced or not. If every response is reinforced, then the reinforcer signals that the next response is likely to be reinforced. If reinforcement occurs only occasionally, then a reinforcer delivered signals that is not likely that the next response will be reinforced. In either case, at the same time the reinforcer is strengthening the responses that it follows, it also is guiding behavior that follows the reinforcer. When reinforcement is intermittent (occasional), the discriminative function of a reinforcer can be complicated: it can signal that reinforcement of a response is unlikely for a while, but thereafter may become more and more likely. For example, in a fixed-ratio 10 schedule, where reinforcers are delivered after every 10 responses, the reinforcer signals both that the next nine responses will not be reinforced, but also that after 10 more responses, a reinforcer will be forthcoming. This in the context of a history of reinforcement according to the fixed-ratio 10 schedule yields a pattern of pausing (not responding) immediately after a reinforcer, followed by a high rate of responding to the next reinforcer.

Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?
Reinforcers also can serve a third function: that of what is called inducing responding. When there is a period of nonreinforcement after a reinforcer delivery, there is strong possibility that behavior other than reinforced response will occur. What that other behavior is depends on what other kinds of things are present in the environment. If, for example, a rat’s lever pressing is reinforced, during the period after a reinforcer and before the operant response resumes, the rat will run in a running wheel if one is available or it will drink copious amounts of water if water is available. This type of behavior in the post-reinforcement period is labeled schedule-induced behavior, and it is determined by the type of reinforcer, the schedule of reinforcement, and the kinds of objects that are available in the environment. There is, for example, research that suggests that alcohol or drug consumption sometimes can be considered examples of schedule-induced behavior.

These three different functions of the reinforcer – strengthening, discriminative stimulus, and response inducing - suggest the complexities of using reinforcers to change behavior. Sometimes, for example, when reinforcers have unexpected effects on behavior, it may not be because there is something “wrong’ with the reinforcer, but simply because we are not considering the multiple ways in which reinforcers might affect behavior. 

A discriminative stimulus is a stimulus that when it is present, generates a particular response and the response is usually faster, more frequent, and more resistant to extinction. The responding behavior is then subjected to discriminative stimulus control. A discriminative stimulus (Sd or SD) is created when the response is reinforced in its presence, but not when it is absent​1​.

For example, a child requests to watch TV, and historically, he is granted more screen time when his Mom has to get on a conference call for work, but never when she doesn’t have to take a call. So having a work-related phone call is an Sd that controls the child’s requesting behavior.

Discrimination and Classical Conditioning

When an originally neutral stimulus is repeatedly paired with an unconditioned stimulus to generate a response, the neural stimulus becomes a conditioned stimulus for that response.

Discrimination and Operant Conditioning

Discriminative stimuli have control over a particular behavior because the behavior is reliably reinforced through positive or negative reinforcement and punishment when the stimuli are present and not when they are absent.

Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?

Stimulus Discrimination Examples

Here are some discriminative stimulus examples.

  • When a child asks for candy, she always gets one during grandma’s visit, but not in her absence. Grandma’s visiting is an Sd that controls the child’s asking behavior.
  • When the traffic light turns green, drivers keep their car going forward, but not when the light turns red. The green light is then an Sd for going while the red light is for stopping.
  • When a manager is present, the employees work faster than when she’s not present. The manager’s presence is an Sd that controls how fast the employees do their work.
  • When Mom is present, the child completes his homework, but when Mom leaves the room, the child stops doing homework. Mom’s presence is an Sd that controls the homework-doing behavior.
  • You give a dog a treat when it barks at a certain person, but not when it barks at another person. Then that first person becomes an Sd that controls the dog’s barking behavior.

Which stimulus signals the availability of reinforcement for responding in its presence?

Stimulus Discrimination vs Generalization

Stimulus generalization is defined as the extension of conditioning so that similar stimuli that have not been reinforced can act as a conditioned stimulus to generate a specific response​2​. Now an individual responds to not only the one stimulus that has been reinforced but also others that share similar characteristics. Generalization can occur in classical conditioning as well as operant conditioning.

For example, the bee stings you. You will begin to fear it resulting in fear conditioning. But you will also begin to fear other insects that look similar. The more similar another insect is to a bee, the more you will fear it.

Your conditioned response (fear) has generalized from the training stimulus (bees) to another stimulus (insects similar to a bee).

Discriminative Stimulus in Parenting

Discriminating stimuli are often used in parenting to help children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) and those with mental retardation​2​.

A branch of non-mainstream psychology, called Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA), has emerged to teach Sd-based techniques to parents who have kids with ASD. These ABA techniques help children develop social skills and decrease behaviors that may interfere with their independence in life​3​.

In ABA therapy, discriminative stimulus and differential reinforcement are used to teach children how to respond appropriately or give a correct answer. An ABA therapist will work with parents to make sure that they understand how to apply the correct techniques.


References

  1. 1.

    Michael J. The Discriminative Stimulus or SD. BEHAV ANALYST. Published online April 1980:47-49. doi:10.1007/bf03392378

  2. 2.

    Foxx RM. Applied Behavior Analysis Treatment of Autism: The State of the Art. Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Clinics of North America. Published online October 2008:821-834. doi:10.1016/j.chc.2008.06.007

  3. 3.

    Alberto P, Troutman AC. Applied Behavior Analysis for Teachers. Pearson Merrill Prentice Hall; 2006.

What signals the availability of reinforcement?

1.4. In nontechnical terms, a discriminative stimulus tells the person what behavior is going to get reinforced—it signals the availability of a particular reinforcer for a particular behavior. The abbreviation for discriminative stimulus is “Sd.”

What kind of stimulus is associated with reinforcement?

In an attempt to increase the likelihood of a behavior occurring in the future, an operant response is followed by the presentation of an appetitive stimulus. This is positive reinforcement.

What signals the absence of reinforcement?

S- A discriminative stimulus that signals the absence of reinforcement for an instrumental response.

When responses are reinforced in the presence of one stimulus the SD but are not reinforced in the presence of another stimulus the SΔ the process is referred to as?

When a response is reinforced in the presence of one stimulus and not in the presence of another, the stimulus during which reinforcement occurs is called a discriminative stimulus or SD (pronounced S-Dee). Those conditions in which the response is not reinforced are called S-Delta.